Affiliate Disclosure: AmmoCave.com sometimes gets paid for listings, through sponsors or affiliate programs like Lucky Gunner, Optics Planet, Brownells, Cabelas, Academy Sports & Outdoors, Rainier Arms, Palmetto State Armory, Sportsman’s Guide, Ammo.com, Ammo Man, Primary Arms, MidWayUsa, Amazon, eBay, etс. Clicking a link helps keep AmmoCave.com free, at no extra cost to you!
Authors: Each article is verified by AmmoCave's expert team. Professional hunters, firearm trainers, gunsmiths, and gun experts write the articles. AmmoCave Team independently researches, tests, reviews, and uses recommendations from our community of gun owners. We may earn commissions from shopping links.
Note: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect any agency's official policy or position. The articles are for informational purposes only, share your opinions about Best 1911 Holster 2024 in the comments and join the discussions. Let's share 💬 our ammo & gun experiences together!
What is a 1911 holster? 🧐
It is a type of gun holster, specifically designed for the Colt M1911 semi-automatic pistol. Also known as a Government Model or simply “1911”, this popular weapon has been in production since before World War I and remains in use today.
Features 📝
- 💥 Material: The material of the holster is crucial to both comfort and durability. Most holsters are made of leather, nylon, or Kydex.
- 💥 Retention: Retention refers to how tightly the holster holds your 1911 pistol in place. The best holsters strike a balance between retention and ease of access, so you can quickly and safely draw your weapon when needed.
- 💥 Design: Some holsters feature an open-top design for easy access, while others have a thumb break or other retention mechanism to keep the gun secure.
- 💥 Comfort: A comfortable holster is critical, especially if you plan on wearing it for extended periods.
- 💥 Concealment: If you plan to carry your 1911 concealed, look for a holster that is designed for that purpose. These holsters are typically made to sit snugly against your body and have a low profile to avoid printing or revealing the presence of your firearm.
- 💥 Versatility: The best holsters are versatile and can be worn in various carry positions, including inside the waistband (IWB), outside the waistband (OWB), and appendix carry.
Benefits 🔥
Carrying a 1911 firearm comes with a lot of responsibility, and choosing the right holster is part of that. Here are some benefits:
- 🔷 Safety: A well-designed holster is essential for safety, not only for the shooter but also for those around them. A good holster will keep the firearm secure and prevent accidental discharges.
- 🔷 Easy Accessibility: Having it allows for quick and easy access to the firearm in case of an emergency. A good holster should provide a smooth draw and easy access to the trigger.
- 🔷 Comfort: Carrying a firearm for extended periods can be uncomfortable, but choosing the right holster can make a big difference. It will distribute the weight of the firearm evenly and prevent hotspots or chafing.
- 🔷 Concealment: This can help to conceal the firearm and prevent printing, which could give away its presence. This is especially important for those who carry a firearm for self-defense or in situations where open carry is not allowed.
How to make a leather holster not so tight? 🤔
If you’re searching for the best 1911 holster, you’re not alone. It’s a popular gun that has been around for over a century, and a good holster is crucial for both safety and comfort. But what do you do if your new leather holster is too tight?
⌛️ Firstly, it’s important to understand why it is tight. Leather holsters are made from natural materials, and they will naturally mold to the shape of your gun over time. However, when they are new, they can be tighter than expected. This is because leather is usually treated with oils and waxes, making it feel denser and stiffer. Additionally, the stitching and design of the holster can also affect the fit.
💡 Here are some tips for making it more comfortable:
- 🧩 Wear your holster around the house: The more you wear it, the quicker it will loosen up. Start by wearing it around the house for a few hours a day. This will gradually stretch the leather and make it more comfortable.
- 🧩 Use leather conditioner: Leather conditioner softens and nourishes the leather, making it more flexible. Apply the conditioner to the inside and outside of your holster and rub it in with a soft cloth.
- 🧩 Use a hairdryer: Use a hairdryer on low heat to warm up the leather around the areas that need to be stretched. Once the leather is warm, use your hand or a tool to pull and stretch the areas that are too tight.
The 23 Best 1911 Concealed Carry Holsters – Editor’s Choice
1# Tagua Gunleather Thumb Break Belt Holster
Introducing the Tagua Gunleather Thumb Break Belt Holster. The holster is designed to ride at a forward angle for a comfortable and natural draw, and double-stitching provides added durability for long-lasting use. Featuring an open muzzle design, this two-piece holster has front molding and a backside body that is molded to provide a secure fit for your firearm. The covered snap prevents the gun from scratching, and the interior of the holster is lined with leather to protect your gun’s finish. Choose this reliable and secure Tagua Gunleather Thumb Break Belt Holster for a comfortable and convenient way to carry your firearm.
2# Tagua Quick Draw Belt Holster
For a discreet and easy way to carry your firearm, consider this Tagua Quick Draw Belt Holster. Its two-piece construction with front molding ensures a secure and comfortable fit, while the completely leather-lined interior adds an extra layer of protection for your firearm. This holster is designed to fit multiple barrel lengths of the same gun model, allowing for flexibility and versatility in your carry options. Based on our experience the belt slots are tailored to fit belts up to 1 inch wide for added convenience. Choose this two-piece holster with front molding and a completely leather-lined interior for a reliable and comfortable way to carry your pistol.
3# Galco S3H Shoulder Holster
Ensure a comfortable and secure fit for your gun with the Galco S3H Shoulder System. This high-quality holster component is available in both right and left-hand draw, allowing you to choose the option that works best for you. Crafted from premium steer hide, this holster component is available in either tan or black, giving you the flexibility to choose a color that suits your style. Choose the Galco S3H Shoulder System for a comfortable, customizable, and versatile way to carry your gun!
4# Fobus Tactical 1911 RH Holster
When you need quick access to your firearm, trust the Fobus Tactical 1911 Holster. Specifically designed to fit 1911 pistols with tactical accessories like laser scopes or lights mounted under the barrel or on the trigger guard, this holster is custom-made to meet your needs. An open withdrawal slot on the rear of the holster also allows for the easy and swift presentation of your weapon. Additionally, the paddle holster style includes a rubberized insert that provides both comfort and stability, making it a comfortable choice for extended wear. Trust the Fobus Tactical 1911 Holster – Holds Light or Laser to keep your firearm secure and accessible in any situation.
5# Galco Yaqui Slide Belt Holster
Galco Yaqui Slide Belt Holster is an updated version of the iconic Yaqui Holster series. Its minimalistic design and near-vertical carry angle allow for fast drawing while keeping the firearm secure during everyday activities. The holster features a circular cut-out on the belt channel to prevent it from shifting on the pant loop. The open-muzzle design is ideal for gun owners with multiple barrel lengths of the same model. Order the Galco Yaqui Slide Belt Holster and try this high-quality product just now!
6# DeSantis Mini Scabbard Belt Holster
Presenting the DeSantis Mini Scabbard Belt Holster – a no-frills option that delivers exceptional performance. Designed with superior weapon retention capabilities, this holster is a reliable choice. It is specifically molded to fit your handgun and features an adjustable tension device for a personalized fit. With a stripped-down, open-top design the unlined leather construction of the DeSantis Mini Scabbard Leather Belt Holster makes it a simple and effective choice for any firearm owner.
7# Fobus Compact Ankle Holsters
Searching for a high-quality ankle holster? Check out the Fobus Compact Ankle Holsters! This lightweight ankle holster has a low profile design that makes it easy to conceal under your pants leg. Using this product, our team found that the suede-lined Cordura pad provides a comfortable fit, and the passive retention system allows for rapid presentation when you need it. If you need a reliable and versatile ankle holster, the Fobus Compact Ankle Holsters are an excellent choice. Order yours today and experience its quality and reliability!
8# BlackHawk Serpa Tactical Level 3 Thigh Holster
Experience the ultimate combination of speed, retention, and comfort with the BlackHawk Serpa Tactical Level 3 Thigh Holster. Designed with a flexible thigh platform that promotes breathability, comfort, and stability, this holster also includes a thumb-activated Pivot Guard and Serpa auto lock release. The Y-harness suspension system distributes weight evenly while quick-disconnect swivel buckles on the belt mounts deliver maximum mobility. The full-length holster body protects your rear sights, while the flexible thigh platform conforms to leg size for a versatile and comfortable fit. Don’t wait – try it today!
9# BlackHawk Serpa Level 2 Tactical Holsters
If you require a versatile tactical holster, the BlackHawk Serpa Level 2 Tactical Holsters are a great option. The thigh platform on this Blackhawk Gun Holster is unique, molding itself to the size of the user’s leg for added comfort. The Y-harness leg straps and quick-release buckles allow for free movement without binding. Thanks to the Serpa retention system, there are no straps, snaps, or rotations to worry about; the holster automatically reholsters your weapon. All these features combined make the BlackHawk Serpa Level 2 Tactical Holsters a top choice for those searching for a comfortable, secure, fast-drawing holster.
10# Scorpus Model M24 Holster
Pay attention to the Scorpus Model M24 Holster. This holster features the Scorpus Level 2 Retention System, which incorporates two opposing retention devices that securely capture the trigger guard of the handgun. One retention device is a pressure-activated locking lever, while the other is a spring-based device. This combined system ensures that the handgun is held securely even when the locking lever is deactivated by the operator. To draw the handgun, the operator must firmly grip the handle, push the pressure-activated locking lever, and perform a clean and smooth draw. This innovative design provides reliable retention and allows for a quick and easy draw when needed.
11# Safariland 6378 ALS Paddle Holster
The Safariland 6378 ALS Paddle Holster is an excellent choice for those seeking a concealable, yet accessible paddle holster with enhanced security features. Our research has shown that the ALS locking system ensures that the firearm is securely locked in place when holstered, yet allows for a quick and natural draw with a simple swipe of the thumb release. The SafariLaminate construction of the holster provides durability and strength, while the SafariSuede lining on the inside protects the firearm’s front sight and finish. So what wait for? Order it just now!
12# Aker Leather 101 Comfort-Flex Shoulder Holster
Check out the Aker Leather 101 Comfort-Flex Shoulder Holster a modernized version of the company’s first and most popular shoulder holster, developed almost three decades ago. A premium quality full-grain leather from North American cowhide is used in crafting this holster, which is ideal for shoulder holsters as it retains the deep mold of the weapon and magazines, ensuring long-lasting use without losing shape while becoming more comfortable over time. Try it today!
13# Comp-Tac International Outside The Waistband Tactical Holster
The Comp-Tac International Outside The Waistband Tactical Holster is the perfect solution to keep your pistol safe and easily accessible during self-defense scenarios. This holster features a cut in the front that makes it compatible with most red dot sights or similar optics. Its modular mounting design offers multiple holster options, and its adjustable cant allows for a straight-up draw, FBI cant, or cross-draw, depending on your preference. Additionally, you can adjust the retention to match your desired level of security. With the Comp-Tac International Outside The Waistband Tactical Holster, you get a versatile model that allows you to customize how you carry your weapon in the field, whether it be with a belt, paddle, or drop offset holster.
14# Cebeci Arms 1911 Horizontal Shoulder Holster w/Rail
Carry your firearm discreetly and comfortably with the Cebeci Arms 1911 Horizontal Shoulder Holster w/Rail. Made from high-quality cowhide leather and suede, this Shoulder Holster from Cebeci Arms provides a stylish and comfortable way to carry your firearm. The fully adjustable tension screws allow you to adjust the holster to your exact specifications. It accommodates semi-automatic pistols and includes a harness and double magazine pouch. With a reinforced thumb break, you can be confident that your firearm will stay secure!
15# Bulldog Cases & Vaults Belt And Clip Ambi Holster
Looking for a high-quality holster for your 1911-style auto? Notice the Bulldog Cases & Vaults Belt And Clip Ambi Holster. It is custom-fit to ensure a perfect fit for your firearm, providing you with the assurance of quality that you need when it comes to carrying your weapon. With its four-wall construction, this holster is designed to be durable and long-lasting. Our findings show that the outer wall is made from heavy-duty, water-resistant nylon, while the inner wall features a vinyl vapor barrier, deluxe padding, and a soft, scratch-resistant fabric to protect your firearm. The ambidextrous clip and belt loop allow you to carry your weapon on either side, making this holster a versatile and practical choice!
16# Galco Classic Lite Shoulder System
The Galco Classic Lite Shoulder System is the latest in a long line of renowned shoulder harnesses from Galco. This holster features a stylish natural finish and is made from durable and affordable center-cut steer hide material. The Flexalon swivel back plate provides you with the freedom of movement you need while wearing the holster. If you want the best fit for your Colt 5″ 1911 revolver, choose the Galco Classic Lite Shoulder System. With its superior quality, durability, and customization options, this Galco shoulder holster is an excellent choice for professionals and enthusiasts alike!
17# BlackHawk Sportster Serpa CMG Paddle Holster
The BlackHawk Sportster Serpa CMG Paddle Holster is a versatile and durable holster suitable for both concealed carry and range use. Based on the original Serpa design, this civilian version features a sturdy paddle mount that allows for quick and easy access to your pistol. With the ability to fit belts up to 2-1/4″, the holster provides a comfortable and adjustable cant, while also maintaining a low profile for discreet carrying. Whether you need a holster for everyday use or more specialized situations, the BlackHawk Sportster Serpa CMG Paddle Holster is a reliable choice to keep you prepared.
18# Galco Fletch Belt Holster
If you’re searching for a comfortable and reliable way to carry you are concealed carry handgun, consider the Galco Fletch Belt Holster. With its F.L.E.T.C.H. high-ride design, this holster is made from premium saddle leather that’s molded to fit specific handguns. The reinforced thumb break, double-stitched seams, and covered trigger guard ensure your firearm stays secure and protected. This holster is made to fit belts up to 1 3/4″ and is available in both right and left-handed designs, making it a versatile choice for any lifestyle. Trust the Galco Fletch Belt Holster to provide the comfort and functionality you need for everyday concealed carry.
19# Galco Ankle Glove Handgun Holster
Carry your firearm for self-defense with discretion using the Galco Ankle Glove Handgun Holster. This top-quality ankle holster features a timeless design with a reliable leather construction that is durable and aesthetically pleasing. The neoprene ankle band of this holster includes a Velcro fastener that provides a comfortable and secure fit. With a reinforced thumb break, the holster adds an extra layer of security to prevent any takeaways in the field. The genuine sheepskin padding ensures you can carry your firearm for extended periods without experiencing discomfort. Choose the right fit for your firearm and carry in style with the Galco Ankle Glove Handgun Holster.
20# BlackHawk Serpa Level 3 Auto Lock Duty Holsters
The BlackHawk Serpa Level 3 Auto Lock Duty Holsters is a reliable tool that can withstand the toughest duties and is suitable for almost any situation. Through trial and error, we found that these holsters use your natural drawing motion to release the weapon, with no complicated sequences to remember. This simple operation is why the BlackHawk Serpa Level 3 Auto Lock Duty Holsters are one of the best on the market!
21# Comp-Tac International Outside The Waistband Holster
Introducing the Comp-Tac International Outside The Waistband Holster is a tough and long-lasting Kydex holster that is perfect for use in competition shooting. Crafted with superior craftsmanship and attention to detail, these holsters are adjustable for a customized fit and feature three mounting options: belt mount, paddle mount, or drop-offset mount. Trust in the reliability and excellent fit of the Comp-Tac International Outside The Waistband Holster for all of your shooting needs.
22# Comp-Tac Paddle Outside The Waistband Holster
Do you want to get a versatile option that excels both in competitive field matches and regular concealed carry use? Check out the Comp-Tac Paddle Outside The Waistband Holster. Crafted from durable Kydex material, these holsters are designed to comply with IDPA, USPSA, and IPSC regulations for use in competitions. What sets the holster apart is its low-friction surface that enables fast, smooth draws while allowing you to quickly and easily re-holster your handgun. Its rigid construction means that the holster retains its shape, even when your pistol is unholstered. It’s high-quality construction and thoughtful design makes it a reliable and effective option for any firearm enthusiast!
23# Comp-Tac MTAC Inside The Waistband Hybrid Concealed Carry Holster
The Comp-Tac MTAC Inside The Waistband Hybrid Concealed Carry Holster is a perfect blend of form and function, combining custom-fit Kydex material with soft cowhide backing to provide superior protection in a stylish package. It is built to last, as its sturdy construction prevents it from bending or stretching over time. It is also resistant to sweat and solvents, ensuring that it will remain a high-quality holster for years to come. Whether you’re heading to the range or simply going about your day-to-day routine, this holster is an excellent choice for anyone seeking a reliable, customizable concealed carry option.
How to choose it? 🔍
Choosing the right holster for your 1911 is a critical decision that can affect the performance and safety of your firearm. Here are some important factors to consider:
⭕ Material – The material used in making the holster is a crucial consideration.
- ➡️ Leather holsters are widely preferred because of their durability, water resistance, and stylish design. They may take some time to get used to but feel comfortable with time.
- ➡️ Polymer, nylon, and Kydex holsters are other popular options due to their lightness, ruggedness, and ease of maintenance. They provide a secure fit, minimal wear, and positive retention while minimizing shock to 1911.
⭕ Retention – Retention describes how well the holster protects the 1911 and keeps it secure while carrying.
- ➡️ The type of retention system can be active or passive. Active retention systems rely on retention straps, thumb snaps, or triggers, while passive systems use pressure retention from the holster itself to keep 1911 secure.
⭕ Design – The design of the holster determines how comfortable and secure it will be during use.
- ➡️ To achieve this, consider designs such as shoulder, ankle, belt, and chest holsters that provide different levels of comfort, accessibility, and concealment based on your activity.
⭕ Level of Concealment – The level of concealment is an essential aspect when choosing the best holster.
- ➡️ If you plan to carry concealed, choose a holster that offers good concealment without affecting accessibility or retention. Holsters such as concealed belts, and ankle, or shoulder holsters are best for discreet carry, while open belt holsters are for general use.
⭕ Price – Price is a crucial consideration when choosing the holster. The price should reflect the quality and durability of the holster.
- ➡️ Don’t go for the cheapest option if you want to get a product that lasts longer and performs optimally. Invest in holsters that are versatile, of excellent quality, and within your budget.
FAQ 🤠
Conclusion 😊
Choosing the right 1911 holster can be a daunting task, but with our comprehensive buyer’s guide and product reviews, you should now have all the information you need to make an informed decision. Remember to consider factors like size, material composition, retention levels, and available accessories when making your choice. With this knowledge in mind, we hope that you find the perfect for yourself! 🥰❤️🔥
Tags: #best 1911 holster / #best 1911 iwb holster / #best holster for 1911 / #best 1911 concealed carry holster / #best 1911 leather holster / #what is the best holster for a 1911
Hey there, I’m looking for recommendations on a holster to conceal carry my 5″ 1911. I currently have a belly band, but it’s not as quick to draw as my SCCY EDC in an IWB holster. I’m hoping to find a more comfortable and efficient holster option that will allow me to easily conceal my 1911 while still being able to draw it quickly if needed. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
I carry a full-size 1911 comfortably at the 5 o’clock position with a forward cant and an untucked shirt. I have tried several forward-leaning holsters but I like the Scorpus Model M24 Holster.
I carry a 5.5″ 1911 and for everyday carry, I prefer leather holsters. The one I’ve been using for the last five years is a DeSantis Mini Scabbard Belt Holster. This holster has been incredibly comfortable for me every day, no matter what I’m doing, except when lying under a car for an extended period.
I have been carrying my Glock 19 for years, but I recently fell in love with the classic tank-like 1911. I am now on the lookout for a good concealment holster for it, specifically an inside-the-belt holster.
As someone who has carried full-size handguns, I tend to prefer combat commanders. These are all-steel, full-size frames with slightly shorter slides. For all my bigger guns, I use hybrid holsters as they offer greater comfort. My new Comp-Tac MTAC Inside The Waistband Hybrid Concealed Carry Holster is by far the most comfortable. Hybrid holsters do an excellent job of distributing weight across your hip, instead of putting it all in one spot. I’ve found they’re also less likely to slide around in my waistband if I have to move around a lot.
I recently purchased my first handgun, a Springfield Armory Loaded Lightweight Operator, and I’m looking for a holster to use with it. I plan on using the gun mainly for the range with the possibility of using it for CCW. Do you have any recommendations or thoughts on what type of holster I should go for?
I’ve personally had great experiences with hybrid holsters. I’ve used it for minimizing printing and retaining the firearm after making adjustments at the 3:30-4 o’clock position, my top pick would have to be Comp-Tac MTAC Inside The Waistband Hybrid Concealed Carry Holster.
I’m looking for a Kydex holster that can be used for range shooting, casual-level competitions, and possibly backpacking. I already own Vedder holsters and like them for my other guns, but I need a new one that can fit a full-size 1911. I’m hoping to hear from others who have experience with this type of holster and can recommend a good brand or model.
I was recently gifted a Safariland 6378 ALS Paddle Holster and I am loving it so far. It’s perfect for my main use, which is range and camping. The thumb retention is a nice feature.
I have an STI Lawman 5.0 and I’m searching for a leather OWB holster to wear while I’m out on the ranch. I’m aware of Galco, but I was hoping to discover a more distinctive option.
I use a DeSantis Mini Scabbard Belt Holster for my 1911 and I am satisfied with its performance. It stays in place and it is comfortable to wear. Overall, I recommend it.